Warning, this story contains details of an alleged sexual assault.
A Victoria massage provider will not be able to appeal an order for a new trial in relation to two counts of sexual assault after a judge found the appeal would not have a “reasonable prospect of success.”
John Heintzelman was acquitted of the charges, which was then appealed by Crown and on Sept. 6, 2019, a summary appeal judge ordered a new trial. Heintzelman argues that the summary appeal judge erred in law by setting aside the acquittal and ordering a new trial.
Court of Appeal Justice Gail Dickson dismissed the application, stating she did not agree with Heintzelman’s submissions and saw no error in the summary appeal judge’s ruling.
RELATED: Rogue masseur arrested for sexual assault in Victoria
Heintzelman operated a massage business from a basement studio in his James Bay home. Heintzelman allegedly sexually assaulted two women, whose names are protected by a publication ban, and can only be identified as E.M. and T.T.
Both E.M. and T.T. were clients of his. The first assault is alleged to have occurred on July 2, 2017.
At trial, E.M. testified that Heintzelman touched her sexually on the breasts and genital area while he was performing a hot stone massage. She reported it to the police four days later and on July 9, 2017 Heintzelman was arrested and released on bail conditions.
A few months later, on Oct. 20, Victoria police posted on Facebook asking for more victims to come forward, naming Heintzelman, along with the current and past names of his business and the location of his studio.
T.T. saw the notice and contacted the police on the same day, alleging Heintzelman sexually touched her breast and genital area during a hot stone massage in December 2013. She told the courts she didn’t come forward earlier because she was on medication for mental health issues.
RELATED: Crown to appeal acquittal of Victoria masseur accused of sexual assault
Court documents show the two women’s accounts of the separate alleged incidents both involved Heintzelman telling them to remove all their clothes and to lie on their backs on his massage table. Both said he placed hot stones under their back and began to massage their body including their genitals and breasts. Both accounts noted he pinched their nipples very hard. Both women said Heintzelman placed their cupped hand under his penis and that he moved his body or their hand in a way that stroked his penis.
Heintzelman denied ever touching them in a sexual manner.
Provincial court Judge Ted Gouge stated each of the witnesses “presented eminently credible,” with Crown counsel submitting that, by reason of the similarity of their accounts, the evidence of each complainant is corroborative of the other.
However, the judge stated in his ruling that two things reduced the “corroborative weight” of the women’s testimony: the potential impact of the one woman’s mental illness on her evidence, and police conduct during the investigation.
Gouge said that he had very little information to assist in assessing the impact, if any, of the one woman’s mental illness or her medication on the reliability of her evidence.
He noted that the Facebook post the Victoria police had published to seek additional witnesses, tainted the ability to test the veracity of the second complaint that came forward.
The summary appeal judge ordered a new trial after finding the trial judge erred in allowing the weight to be given on such evidence to be affected by “what appears to have been speculations about the possible impact on that evidence of the psychiatric condition and medications taken by one of the complainants.” The judge went on to state this error was supplemented by the trial judge’s treatment of the media release and its possible impact on the evidence from both women.
Heintzelman appeared in court on Jan. 13 to fix a date but was adjourned to Feb. 20.
[email protected]
Follow us on Instagram
Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.
Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here
A Victoria massage provider will not be able to appeal an order for a new trial in relation to two counts of sexual assault after a judge found the appeal would not have a “reasonable prospect of success.”
John Heintzelman was acquitted of the charges, which was then appealed by Crown and on Sept. 6, 2019, a summary appeal judge ordered a new trial. Heintzelman argues that the summary appeal judge erred in law by setting aside the acquittal and ordering a new trial.
Court of Appeal Justice Gail Dickson dismissed the application, stating she did not agree with Heintzelman’s submissions and saw no error in the summary appeal judge’s ruling.
RELATED: Rogue masseur arrested for sexual assault in Victoria
Heintzelman operated a massage business from a basement studio in his James Bay home. Heintzelman allegedly sexually assaulted two women, whose names are protected by a publication ban, and can only be identified as E.M. and T.T.
Both E.M. and T.T. were clients of his. The first assault is alleged to have occurred on July 2, 2017.
At trial, E.M. testified that Heintzelman touched her sexually on the breasts and genital area while he was performing a hot stone massage. She reported it to the police four days later and on July 9, 2017 Heintzelman was arrested and released on bail conditions.
A few months later, on Oct. 20, Victoria police posted on Facebook asking for more victims to come forward, naming Heintzelman, along with the current and past names of his business and the location of his studio.
T.T. saw the notice and contacted the police on the same day, alleging Heintzelman sexually touched her breast and genital area during a hot stone massage in December 2013. She told the courts she didn’t come forward earlier because she was on medication for mental health issues.
RELATED: Crown to appeal acquittal of Victoria masseur accused of sexual assault
Court documents show the two women’s accounts of the separate alleged incidents both involved Heintzelman telling them to remove all their clothes and to lie on their backs on his massage table. Both said he placed hot stones under their back and began to massage their body including their genitals and breasts. Both accounts noted he pinched their nipples very hard. Both women said Heintzelman placed their cupped hand under his penis and that he moved his body or their hand in a way that stroked his penis.
Heintzelman denied ever touching them in a sexual manner.
Provincial court Judge Ted Gouge stated each of the witnesses “presented eminently credible,” with Crown counsel submitting that, by reason of the similarity of their accounts, the evidence of each complainant is corroborative of the other.
However, the judge stated in his ruling that two things reduced the “corroborative weight” of the women’s testimony: the potential impact of the one woman’s mental illness on her evidence, and police conduct during the investigation.
Gouge said that he had very little information to assist in assessing the impact, if any, of the one woman’s mental illness or her medication on the reliability of her evidence.
He noted that the Facebook post the Victoria police had published to seek additional witnesses, tainted the ability to test the veracity of the second complaint that came forward.
The summary appeal judge ordered a new trial after finding the trial judge erred in allowing the weight to be given on such evidence to be affected by “what appears to have been speculations about the possible impact on that evidence of the psychiatric condition and medications taken by one of the complainants.” The judge went on to state this error was supplemented by the trial judge’s treatment of the media release and its possible impact on the evidence from both women.
Heintzelman appeared in court on Jan. 13 to fix a date but was adjourned to Feb. 20.
[email protected]
Follow us on Instagram
Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.
Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here
Spin the Wheel, Feel the Bliss! 
A Lucky Boy, right? Now it’s YOUR turn to relax and play! There’s still time to spin for surprises and snag amazing deals. Come for the ultimate Asian massage, stay for the thrill. Discounts? Treats? Who knows what YOU could win? 
Don’t miss out—book your spot at Shangri-La Spa or the West Location today! 
Where to Spin: Shangri-La & SL West's Front Desks
ladies
New addition Nora, along with Gina, Michelle, Sunny, Jojo, Jessie and Alice 🛣 420 ValleymedeDr, Richmond Hill, same plaza McDonalds 
☎ 905-597-8880 ☎
Endless Joy Spa
(155 East Beaver Creek Rd Unit #8, Richmond Hill) 416-731-8565
4376655510 
️
We have 5 hot brown girls today 
SPARKLING SPA
50 Lockridge Ave Unit 8
Markham, ON L3R 8X4
Viennese 
working at Nu spring spa
Natural Big Boobs 38 DD 
Hot body slide, super enjoyable
JENNY’S SPA
Amy is Vietnamese young sex girl,open maid,
𝐀 𝐒𝐏𝐀
𝓕𝓞𝓡𝓔𝓥𝓔𝓡 𝓢𝓟𝓐
𝓗𝓸𝓵𝓲𝓭𝓪𝔂 𝓢𝓹𝓪
⎝𝗦𝗨𝗚𝗔𝗥 𝗟𝗢𝗩𝗘 𝗦𝗣𝗔⎠
: CINDY, ELLA & TIFFANY. 1270 Finch Ave W (at Keele St), Unit 18. North York, ON ☎ 𝟰𝟯𝟳-𝟯𝟲𝟱-𝟮𝟲𝟴𝟴 ☎
A new arrival at our branch 
Vicky is a very young CBC part time student working for tuition fees and books, this bright young sexy girl is willing to showcase her eagerness to please AND be pleased. Busty 36DD boobs
We're Open from 8am til Late Everyday! Drop in to Unit 26, 10 East Wilmot Street, Richmond Hill.
𝗛𝗢𝗟𝗟𝗬𝗪𝗢𝗢𝗗 𝗦𝗣𝗔
♀
9 stunning Girls from China, HK, Japan & Korea — 34D Suki, Cindy, 
Queen Selena, Kelly, Busty Echo, JPN Yui & 
Jessica — 
♀
Hit up 647-695-6354
or text to 
647-578-8169 
Let the fun times roll, baby!
address: #5-30 Rambler dr Brampton ,Ontario L6W 1E2
